SlablineSlabline™All articles →

Insurance · 4 min read · June 20, 2026

Card Collection Stolen or Damaged? What to Do

Nobody wants to think about it, but theft, fire, water, and accidents happen — and whether you are made whole depends almost entirely on what you documented before the loss. Here is the playbook.

The work happens before the loss

A claim is only as strong as your records. Keep a current, itemized schedule — each card, grade, cert number, and a comp-based value with the date valued — and store a copy off-site or in the cloud. Without it, a carrier has little to pay against.

After a loss

File a police report for theft, document the damage with photos, notify your insurer promptly, and submit your schedule as proof of what you owned and what it was worth. The cleaner your records, the faster and fairer the payout.

Keep the schedule current

An outdated value means an under-payment. Slabline keeps your Schedule & Risk Report current from live comps, so the documentation you would hand a claims adjuster reflects today’s market, not a years-old appraisal.

Frequently asked questions

What do I do if my card collection is stolen?

File a police report immediately, notify your insurer, and provide your pre-loss documentation — cert numbers, photographs, and valued schedule. Claims settle on proof that predates the loss; a collection described from memory typically settles at the sub-limit.

What documentation do I need to file a card collection insurance claim?

Certification numbers proving authenticity, dated photographs proving condition and possession, and a comp-backed valuation for each card. An itemized, valued schedule prepared before the loss is what separates a paid claim from a disputed one.

Browse graded card values

Know what your collection is worth — with gem rate and population across PSA, BGS, SGC & CGC — and how well you’re protecting it.

Build your free Slabline Score →
Or get the app — iPhone & AndroidDownload on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Slabline Brief

One email a month: where graded-card values drifted, and what it means for how your collection is protected.

Monthly, no noise between issues, unsubscribe anytime.