2023 Tom Bombadil [Serialized] #745 PSA 10 $14,000
2023 Radagast the Brown [Borderless Poster] #740 PSA 10 $10,376
2023 Mount Doom [Serialized] #750 PSA 10 $8,931
2023 The One Ring [Alternate Art Borderless Foil] #748 PSA 10 $5,406
2023 Arwen, Mortal Queen [Serialized] #742 PSA 10 $3,000
2023 The One Ring [Extended Art Foil] #380 +131.2% 1W PSA 10 $2,638
2023 Glamdring [Serialized] #747 PSA 10 $2,458
2023 The One Ring [Prerelease] #246 PSA 10 $2,374
2023 Witch-king of Angmar [Foil] #114 PSA 10 $2,275
2023 Forest [Foil] #281 PSA 10 $2,120
2023 Tom Bombadil [Borderless Poster Foil] #745 PSA 10 $2,002
2023 The One Ring [Surge Foil] #791 PSA 10 $1,825
2023 The One Ring [Alternate Art Borderless] #748 PSA 10 $1,816
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West [Serialized] #746 PSA 10 $1,784
2023 Shadow of the Enemy #558 PSA 10 $1,700
2023 Mount Doom [Borderless Poster Foil] #750 PSA 10 $1,625
2023 Palantir of Orthanc [Borderless Poster Foil] #749 PSA 10 $1,500
2023 Radagast the Brown [Borderless Poster Foil] #740 PSA 10 $1,350
2023 Dawn of a New Age [Serialized] #731 PSA 10 $1,300
2023 Mount Doom [Showcase Foil] #709 PSA 10 $1,175
2023 Mount Doom [Borderless Poster] #750 PSA 10 $1,075
2023 Tom Bombadil [Borderless Poster] #745 PSA 10 $860
2023 Arwen, Mortal Queen [Borderless Poster Foil] #742 PSA 10 $850
2023 Last March of the Ents [Borderless Poster Foil] #739 PSA 10 $800
2023 Spiteful Banditry [Showcase] #600 PSA 10 $750
2023 Storm of Saruman [Borderless Poster] #733 PSA 10 $750
2023 Ringwraiths #284 PSA 10 $660
2023 Arwen, Mortal Queen [Borderless Poster] #742 PSA 10 $621
2023 Saruman of Many Colors [Showcase] #328 PSA 10 $600
2023 The One Ring [Showcase] #697 PSA 10 $504
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West [Foil] #236 PSA 10 $500
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #333 PSA 10 $500
2023 Shadow of the Enemy [Borderless Poster Foil] #735 PSA 10 $481
2023 The One Ring [Extended Art] #380 PSA 10 $468
2023 Gandalf the White [Showcase] #305 PSA 10 $425
2023 The Watcher in the Water [Serialized] #734 PSA 10 $404
2023 The One Ring [Scene Foil] #451 +0.8% 1W PSA 10 $371
2023 Hew the Entwood [Borderless Poster Foil] #737 PSA 10 $350
2023 The One Ring #246 PSA 10 $327
2023 Glamdring [Alternate Art Borderless] #747 PSA 10 $300
2023 Shadow of the Enemy [Borderless Poster] #735 PSA 10 $268
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West #687 PSA 10 $265
2023 Dawn of a New Age [Borderless Poster] #731 PSA 10 $257
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #338 +24.2% 1W PSA 10 $252
2023 Witch-king, Bringer of Ruin [Foil] #293 PSA 10 $250
2023 Glamdring [Extended Art] #787 PSA 10 $217
2023 Aragorn, the Uniter [Foil] #192 PSA 10 $212
2023 Palantir of Orthanc #247 PSA 10 $210
2023 Nazgul #551 PSA 10 $205
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West [Alternate Art Borderless] #746 PSA 10 $201
2023 Aragorn and Arwen, Wed #287 PSA 10 $200
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #336 PSA 10 $198
2023 Sauron, the Dark Lord [Foil] #224 PSA 10 $195
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #100 PSA 10 $190
2023 Nazgul #723 PSA 10 $187
2023 Saruman of Many Colors #820 PSA 10 $185
2023 Eowyn, Fearless Knight [Foil] #201 PSA 10 $183
2023 Nazgul #725 PSA 10 $180
2023 Orcish Bowmasters [Borderless Foil] #433 PSA 10 $163
2023 The One Ring [Foil] #246 PSA 10 $157
2023 Witch-king of Angmar #803 PSA 10 $156
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #339 -0.2% 1W PSA 10 $153
2023 Gandalf, Friend of the Shire [Foil] #401 PSA 10 $150
2023 Orcish Bowmasters [Foil] #103 PSA 10 $150
2023 Orcish Bowmasters [Showcase] #554 PSA 10 $150
2023 Call of the Ring [Foil] #79 PSA 10 $149
2023 Gandalf, Friend of the Shire #800 PSA 10 $145
2023 Nazgul #726 PSA 10 $145
2023 Sauron, the Dark Lord [Showcase] #329 PSA 10 $145
2023 Gollum, Patient Plotter #450 PSA 10 $140
2023 Tom Bombadil [Showcase] #331 PSA 10 $140
2023 Sauron, the Necromancer [Showcase] #310 PSA 10 $133
2023 The Balrog, Durin's Bane [Foil] #195 PSA 10 $129
2023 Galadriel of Lothlorien [Showcase] #321 PSA 10 $125
2023 The Watcher in the Water #526 PSA 10 $125
2023 There and Back Again [Foil] #151 PSA 10 $125
2023 The Shire [Borderless] #345 PSA 10 $124
2023 Arwen, Mortal Queen [Foil] #193 PSA 10 $120
2023 Gandalf the White #442 PSA 10 $120
2023 Gandalf, Friend of the Shire [Foil] #50 PSA 10 $120
2023 Nazgul #334 PSA 10 $116
2023 Witch-king of Angmar [Showcase] #311 PSA 10 $116
2023 Minas Tirith [Borderless Foil] #341 PSA 10 $113
2023 The Ring Goes South [Extended Art] #366 PSA 10 $112
2023 Eowyn, Fearless Knight #430 PSA 10 $110
2023 Last March of the Ents #418 PSA 10 $110
2023 Minas Tirith #420 PSA 10 $110
2023 The Balrog, Durin's Bane [Borderless Foil] #405 PSA 10 $110
2023 One Ring to Rule Them All #102 -0.2% 1W PSA 10 $109
2023 Gandalf the White #19 PSA 10 $108
2023 Merry, Esquire of Rohan [Showcase] #325 PSA 10 $103
2023 Gandalf the White #797 PSA 10 $101
2023 Dawn of a New Age [Foil] #5 PSA 10 $100
2023 Gollum, Patient Plotter [Foil] #450 PSA 10 $100
2023 Horn of Gondor [Foil] #240 PSA 10 $100
2023 Peregrin Took #807 PSA 10 $100
2023 Phial of Galadriel [Foil] #248 PSA 10 $100
2023 Sauron, the Lidless Eye [Foil] #288 PSA 10 $100
2023 Doors of Durin [Foil] #199 PSA 10 $100
2023 Nazgul #339 PSA 10 $99
2023 Gimli, Mournful Avenger [Foil] #209 PSA 10 $99
2023 Aragorn, the Uniter #434 PSA 10 $98
2023 Ringwraiths [Foil] #284 PSA 10 $97
2023 Frodo Baggins [Showcase Foil] #320 PSA 10 $96
2023 You Cannot Pass! [Foil] #38 PSA 10 $96
2023 Nazgul #730 PSA 10 $94
2023 Witch-king of Angmar #423 PSA 10 $94
2023 Gollum, Patient Plotter [Showcase] #309 PSA 10 $93
2023 Dunland Crebain #411 PSA 10 $90
2023 Gloin, Dwarf Emissary [Extended Art] #360 PSA 10 $90
2023 Shagrat, Loot Bearer [Extended Art] #372 PSA 10 $90
2023 Nazgul #332 PSA 10 $89
2023 Last March of the Ents [Foil] #172 PSA 10 $88
2023 Orcish Bowmasters #103 +0.1% 1W PSA 10 $87
2023 Forest #281 PSA 10 $85
2023 Fiery Inscription [Foil] #126 PSA 10 $84
2023 Aragorn, the Uniter [Showcase] #317 PSA 10 $83
2023 Nazgul #338 PSA 10 $83
2023 Fiery Inscription #577 PSA 10 $80
2023 Green Dragon Inn #365 PSA 10 $80
2023 Sauron, the Dark Lord [Showcase Foil] #329 PSA 10 $79
2023 Frodo Baggins #205 PSA 10 $75
2023 Legolas, Counter of Kills [Showcase] #324 PSA 10 $75
2023 Nazgul #333 PSA 10 $75
2023 Orcish Bowmasters #433 PSA 10 $75
2023 Rivendell [Foil] #259 PSA 10 $75
2023 Sauron, the Necromancer [Foil] #106 PSA 10 $75
2023 The One Ring #451 PSA 10 $75
2023 Frodo, Sauron's Bane [Foil] #448 PSA 10 $74
2023 Aragorn, the Uniter #192 PSA 10 $70
2023 Flame of Anor #406 PSA 10 $70
2023 Legolas, Master Archer #173 PSA 10 $70
2023 Nazgul #100 PSA 10 $70
2023 Nazgul #336 PSA 10 $70
2023 Nazgul [Foil] #337 PSA 10 $70
2023 The Shire #711 PSA 10 $70
2023 The Balrog, Durin's Bane #405 PSA 10 $68
2023 Nazgul #335 PSA 10 $67
2023 Call of the Ring #530 PSA 10 $65
2023 Palantir of Orthanc #381 PSA 10 $65
2023 Samwise the Stouthearted [Foil] #449 PSA 10 $65
2023 Sauron, the Dark Lord #224 PSA 10 $65
2023 Smeagol, Helpful Guide #231 PSA 10 $65
2023 Galadriel of Lothlorien #206 PSA 10 $62
2023 Last March of the Ents #172 PSA 10 $62
2023 Mithril Coat [Foil] #245 PSA 10 $61
2023 Mountain [Foil] #279 PSA 10 $61
2023 Frodo Baggins [Showcase] #320 PSA 10 $60
2023 Gandalf the Grey [Showcase] #322 PSA 10 $60
2023 Gandalf, Friend of the Shire #50 PSA 10 $60
2023 Gimli, Mournful Avenger [Showcase] #323 PSA 10 $60
2023 Meriadoc Brandybuck [Showcase] #314 PSA 10 $60
2023 Storm of Saruman [Foil] #72 PSA 10 $60
2023 Barad-dur [Borderless] #340 PSA 10 $59
2023 Nazgul #337 PSA 10 $59
2023 Arwen, Mortal Queen [Extended Art] #367 PSA 10 $58
2023 Call of the Ring [Extended Art] #355 PSA 10 $57
2023 Mount Doom [Borderless] #343 PSA 10 $57
2023 Shadowfax, Lord of Horses #227 PSA 10 $57
2023 Barad-dur #704 PSA 10 $56
2023 Delighted Halfling [Foil] #158 PSA 10 $56
2023 Island #274 PSA 10 $55
2023 Mines of Moria [Borderless] #342 PSA 10 $54
2023 Shelob, Child of Ungoliant [Foil] #230 PSA 10 $54
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West #236 PSA 10 $53
2023 Radagast the Brown #635 PSA 10 $53
2023 One Ring To Rule Them All [Foil] #102 PSA 10 $52
2023 Elrond, Lord of Rivendell [Showcase] #307 PSA 10 $51
2023 Galadriel, Gift-Giver #296 PSA 10 $50
2023 Saruman of Many Colors #223 PSA 10 $50
2023 Spiteful Banditry #149 PSA 10 $50
2023 Many Partings #445 PSA 10 $49
2023 Boromir, Warden of the Tower [Showcase] #302 PSA 10 $48
2023 Nasty End #416 PSA 10 $48
2023 Gollum's Bite #85 PSA 10 $45
2023 The Balrog, Durin's Bane #195 PSA 10 $45
2023 The Shire #260 PSA 10 $45
2023 Anduril, Flame of the West [Extended Art] #375 PSA 10 $45
2023 Mines of Moria [Borderless] #753 PSA 10 $43
2023 Bilbo's Ring #298 PSA 10 $42
2023 Lorien Revealed #60 PSA 10 $40
2023 There and Back Again #151 PSA 10 $40
2023 The Balrog, Flame of Udun #297 PSA 10 $38
2023 Samwise Gamgee #819 PSA 10 $37
2023 Samwise the Stouthearted [Showcase] #306 PSA 10 $37
2023 Delighted Halfling #402 PSA 10 $36
2023 Gandalf the Grey #207 PSA 10 $36
2023 The Grey Havens #443 PSA 10 $35
2023 Voracious Fell Beast #422 PSA 10 $35
2023 Ugluk of the White Hand #235 PSA 10 $35
2023 Plains #273 PSA 10 $32
2023 Arwen Undomiel #194 PSA 10 $31
2023 Mines of Moria #257 PSA 10 $30
2023 Mithril Coat #245 PSA 10 $30
2023 Prince Imrahil the Fair #431 PSA 10 $30
2023 Swamp #277 PSA 10 $30
2023 The Grey Havens #255 PSA 10 $30
2023 The Watcher in the Water #75 PSA 10 $30
2023 Mithril Coat [Extended Art] #379 PSA 10 $29
2023 Samwise Gamgee #222 PSA 10 $28
2023 Mountain #279 PSA 10 $26
2023 Elanor Gardner #286 PSA 10 $25
2023 Minas Tirith #256 PSA 10 $25
2023 Sting, the Glinting Dagger #409 PSA 10 $25
2023 Elrond, Lord of Rivendell [Showcase Foil] #307 PSA 10 $24
2023 Fiery Inscription #126 PSA 10 $24
2023 Gimli, Counter of Kills [Showcase] #312 PSA 10 $23
2023 Lost Isle Calling #444 PSA 10 $23
2023 Bilbo's Ring [Extended Art] #397 PSA 10 $21
2023 Flowering of the White Tree #15 PSA 10 $21
2023 Radagast the Brown #184 PSA 10 $20
2023 Delighted Halfling #158 PSA 10 $19
2023 Aragorn, the Uniter #809 PSA 10 $18
2023 Last March of the Ents #623 PSA 10 $15
2023 Gandalf the White [Foil] #19 PSA 10 $9
2023 Legolas, Master Archer [Foil] #173 PSA 10 $6
2023 Elrond, Master of Healing [Foil] #200 PSA 10 $4
2023 Many Partings #176 PSA 10 —
2023 Sauron, the Dark Lord [Borderless Poster Foil] #744 PSA 10 —
