Baseball · Set
1954 Johnston Cookies card values Baseball index -1.20% this week → Current market values for graded cards from Johnston Cookies, by grade, from real comparable sales. Track your whole collection — with a 0–1000 protection score and a broker-ready insurance schedule — free.
Start my collection → Also on iPhone 1954 — every Johnston Cookies card we hold
Show Value ↓ Value ↑ Card # Top 10 Rookies 4 13 of 13 cards
1954 Hank Aaron #5 PSA 9 $34,995 PSA 8 $17,138 SGC 8.5 $11,100
1954 Warren Spahn #21 PSA 9 $644 PSA 10 $144 PSA 6 $55
1954 Ed Mathews #41 PSA 7 $397
1954 Robert Keely #35 1954 Robert Keely #35 PSA 9 $350
1954 Dave Jolly #17 1954 Dave Jolly #17 PSA 8 $106
1954 Charles Grimm #40 1954 Charles Grimm #40 PSA 8 $84
1954 Bob Thomson #34 SGC 2 $81
1954 John Cooney #28 1954 John Cooney #28 PSA 8 $70
1954 Robert Buhl #10 1954 Robert Buhl #10 PSA 8 $66
1954 Charles Gorin #15 PSA 8 $18
1954 Jim Pendleton #3 PSA 8 $15
1954 Chet Nichols #16 1954 Chet Nichols #16 PSA 6 $8
1954 Joe Adcock #9 1954 Joe Adcock #9 SGC 5 $6
All Baseball cards All graded cards How Slabline values cards Values are informational estimates from recent comparable sales — not a certified appraisal, insurance, or financial advice.
