How much is a PSA 1 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?

A PSA 1 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth approximately $240, the median of its 5 most recent recorded sales at this grade. Card values fluctuate with the market.

How does Slabline value the Mickey Mantle card?

Slabline starts from the price guides for the card and grade. When it holds dated recorded sales of that exact card and grade — from CardHedge market data and the auction houses it ingests — the headline becomes the median of the most recent ones and the grade ladder rescales to match. Each row on the page names which of those it is.

How much is a raw (ungraded) 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?

A raw (ungraded) 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $275, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.

How much is a PSA 9 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?

A PSA 9 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $312, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.

How much is a PSA 9.5 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?

A PSA 9.5 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $344, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.

Slabline^™All graded cards →

1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle

What a PSA 1 is worth — from its recorded sales.

Estimated value · PSA 1

$240

Median of the last 5 recorded PSA 1 sales · Jul 2026 – Sep 2026

Last sale

$185 · Sep 7

12-month range

$131–$290

130recorded sales

Recorded sales · all grades

Highest Baseball sales →

ⓘ Where these sales come from

eBay, Fanatics Collect, Alt, MySlabs, Goldin and Heritage records arrive through CardHedge's licensed feed; REA, SCP and Huggins & Scott are read from each house's published prices realized. More eBay, Goldin and auction sales come from The Card API.

Sales seen on eBay, Fanatics Collect, Goldin, Heritage, Alt and MySlabs, via CardHedge. "Marketplace" is a real CardHedge sale whose venue is not identified yet.

Marketplaces only · 128 sales · 2021–2026

▼ 7.5% since Nov 2025

Hover for any sale · click to find it in the list

Sep 7, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$185
Aug 10, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$240
Jul 24, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$131
Jul 19, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$260
Jul 17, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$260
Jul 12, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$245
Jul 10, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$173
Jul 8, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$259
Jul 4, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$239
Jun 23, 2026 · Marketplace · PSA 1$198

Add to my collection — free →

Free · no account needed to start

Trading this card? Price both sides →

See live listings on eBay →

Slabline may earn a commission from eBay purchases.

1961 Phillies Cigar checklistChecklist→Baseball index-1.2% 1W Mickey Mantle index+4.9% 1W

At a glance

A PSA 1 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $240, the median of its 5 most recent recorded PSA 1 sales. Slabline holds 130 recorded PSA 1 sales of this card between October 2021 and September 2026; the most recent sold for $185 on September 7, 2026. At other grades it is valued at about $275 (Raw / Ungraded), $312 (Grade 9), $344 (Grade 9.5).

Sales by grade · weekly median

Each point is one week's median recorded sale · tap the chart to read it

Value by grade

How much the 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth at each grade.

How to read this page: an estimate is Slabline's figure for a grade, built from the source named beside it. An observed price is the latest price a grader's copy of this card fetched, one cell per grader and grade in the grid below. A recorded sale is a dated transaction with its venue. The headline above is the estimate for this slab's own grade.

Grade	Value	Built from
Raw / Ungraded	$275	guide, rescaled to sales
Grade 9	$312	guide, rescaled to sales
Grade 9.5	$344	guide, rescaled to sales

Price guide data: SportsCardsPro

Loading every grader…

Tracked history · PSA 1

Current value

$240

Recorded sales, past year (all grades)

Price checked today · last recorded sale 2 months ago (PSA 1) · 1 sale in the last 90 days (all grades)

If you had to sell today

Liquidity

Market value

$240

→

Quick-sale recovery

≈ $120

50% recovered

A dealer typically pays about 50% of market for a fast, guaranteed sale — the rest is the liquidity gap. An auction or private sale can recover more but takes time and fees. It’s why your Slabline Score weighs liquidity — and why insuring at market matters: a fire-sale recovers far less than the number you’re covered for.

Estimated from dealer buy-vs-sell spreads; actual offers vary by condition and demand.

Grading tools

✦ Pre-Grade from a photo Free AIThe grade a raw copy would likely get, before you pay to submit.

Own this card? List it on ebay straight from your Slabline collection — prefilled title, photo and price, one tap.→

Trading this card? Check the trade → · Ripping slab packs? See the real EV → · both sides priced per cert, liquidity-adjusted, free.

If you own this $240 card: a standard homeowners policy typically pays a few hundred dollars for stolen collectibles — and nothing at all for flood.

See what you'd actually get back →

Prefilled with $240 · 20 seconds · no account

✦ Own this card?

Track it free — worth about $240 today

My copy is

Value re-priced dailySell vs hold vs regrade, side by sideInsurance-ready recordNo account needed

Add to my collection →

Or get the app

Ask Slabline

answers only from this card's data

Anything about Mickey Mantle?

Put this value on your site

A small badge that shows this card’s current Slabline value and links back to this page. It updates on its own.

Frequently asked

How much is a PSA 1 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?: A PSA 1 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth approximately $240, the median of its 5 most recent recorded sales at this grade. Card values fluctuate with the market.
How does Slabline value the Mickey Mantle card?: Slabline starts from the price guides for the card and grade. When it holds dated recorded sales of that exact card and grade — from CardHedge market data and the auction houses it ingests — the headline becomes the median of the most recent ones and the grade ladder rescales to match. Each row on the page names which of those it is.
How much is a raw (ungraded) 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?: A raw (ungraded) 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $275, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.
How much is a PSA 9 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?: A PSA 9 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $312, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.
How much is a PSA 9.5 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle worth?: A PSA 9.5 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle is worth about $344, based on recent comparable sales. Values move with the market — track it free in Slabline to see the current number.
How much would I actually get selling the 1961 Phillies Cigar Mickey Mantle?: A quick sale to a dealer typically recovers about 50% of market value — roughly $120 on this card's $240 value. An auction or private sale can recover more but takes longer and charges fees. The gap between market value and quick-sale recovery is the card's liquidity risk.

Related cards

Guides

Own this card? Track its value automatically.

Add it to your free Slabline collection — live valuations, a 0–1000 protection score, and a broker-ready insurance schedule.

Add to my collection — free →

See a full baseball collection scored →

Values are informational estimates built from recent comparable sales — not a certified appraisal, insurance, or financial advice. Card values fluctuate; figures are a snapshot and may differ from a realized sale.